top of page

WHAT YOUR TEAM NEEDS THAT NO INCENTIVE CAN BUY

Writer: Susana de los Reyes
Susana de los Reyes
Nov 3
4 min read
Taula de treball d’un estudi d’arquitectura amb plànols compartits, anotacions i una idea destacada i incorporada al projecte, com a representació del reconeixement de les aportacions en un equip.
Image generated with ChatGPT.

A professional at an architecture firm spends two years suggesting improvements to the way projects are allocated across teams. The improvements work and save time, but no one ever tells him that they have noticed. One day he leaves, and management puts it down to the usual explanation: the market is tight and competitors pay better.


It is a convenient explanation and, according to more than fifty years of research into human motivation, probably an incomplete one.


The incentive myth


Many people management models are based on an assumption that is rarely questioned: that we are driven, above all, by what we receive in return. If you want greater commitment, “increase the bonus”. If someone is unhappy, “raise their salary”.


In 1971, psychologist Edward Deci tested this idea with a simple experiment. He paid a group of students to solve puzzles they already found interesting. When he stopped paying them, those students spent less of their free time on the puzzles than the group who had never been paid. The financial reward had turned play into work.


Almost thirty years later, a meta-analysis of 128 experiments confirmed the pattern: tangible rewards tied to performing a task tend to reduce intrinsic motivation. And it found something less frequently cited that matters greatly here: among adults, positive feedback — verbal recognition of something a person has done well — tended to increase it.


This does not mean that salary does not matter. Unfair pay is demotivating, very much so. What the research shows is that what sustains high-quality motivation lies elsewhere.


Three needs that play out between people


Edward Deci and Richard Ryan developed this insight into Self-Determination Theory, one of the most robust frameworks in contemporary psychology. Its central idea is that there are three basic psychological needs and that, when they are satisfied, high-quality motivation, well-being and sustained performance emerge:


  • The need for autonomy. Feeling that I do what I do of my own volition, that I can make suggestions, express opinions and decide how I do it. It does not mean independence or doing whatever one wants; it means being able to endorse what one is doing.

  • The need for competence. Feeling that I am effective, that what I do has an impact and that I can grow.

  • The need for relatedness. Feeling that I matter to others and that others matter to me.


None of these three needs is satisfied in isolation. All three depend on the quality of our relationships with the people we work with. This is where the connection with Relational Quality lies.


How the needs of Self-Determination Theory can be understood through Relational Quality


At Instituto Relacional, we define Relational Quality as the capacity of a system of relationships — a team, an area or an entire organisation — to sustain its objectives, people’s well-being and its continuity over time. It comprises three dimensions: Relational Efficiency, Safety and Well-being, and Recognition.

They are not the same three needs under different names. They are the relational conditions that enable those needs to be satisfied — or cause them to be frustrated.


Relational Efficiency supports competence. Think of a warehouse and a customer service team that depend on each other but have never agreed on what information each needs. Everyone may do their own part well and the order can still go wrong. Without coordination, no one can truly feel effective.


Safety and Well-being support autonomy and relatedness. I can only make suggestions, disagree or make mistakes if I do not pay a price for doing so. Commercial aviation learned this the hard way: for years, some preventable accidents occurred because someone in the cockpit spotted an error but did not dare to speak up. Without safety, autonomy remains on the organisational chart.


Recognition is the hinge connecting all three. When the system confirms to someone that their contribution has been seen and that they matter, it nurtures their competence (“what I do has an impact”) and their relatedness (“I matter here”). And when what is recognised is their own initiative, it also nurtures autonomy (“my judgement has a place here”). Think back to the case at the beginning: that professional suggested improvements on his own initiative, and those improvements worked. He had autonomy and competence. What was missing was someone noticing. Without recognition, the other two needs lose their meaning.


Not all recognition actually recognises


Deci and Ryan add an important nuance: the same gesture can work in two different ways.


  • In an Informational way: the person is told something true about what they have contributed and the impact it has had.

  • In a Controlling way: it is used to direct their behaviour.


The first nurtures a professional’s motivation. The second, even when it takes the form of praise, can reduce it because it is experienced as pressure.


That is why the recognition we are interested in is not an employee-of-the-month award or a generic “good job”. We are interested in specific recognition, linked to a real contribution and its impact, born from genuinely paying attention. We sum it up in a phrase that owes much to Martin Buber: to recognise is to allow an encounter to take place.


As a leader, I would like to ask you three questions about your team


  • Does each person know what others need from them for their work to go well?

  • What happens in your team when someone points out a mistake or disagrees?

  • When was the last time someone knew that their specific contribution had made a difference?


People do not leave organisations only for money. They leave when they stop finding in them what they need in order to want to stay. Those needs have had names for decades, and they are satisfied or frustrated in a very specific place: the space between people. That is what Relational Quality allows us to see, measure and develop.


BySUSANA DE LOS REYES.

 

References

  • Deci, E. L. (1971). Effects of externally mediated rewards on intrinsic motivation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 18(1), 105–115.

  • Deci, E. L., Koestner, R. y Ryan, R. M. (1999). A meta-analytic review of experiments examining the effects of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation. Psychological Bulletin, 125(6), 627–668.

  • Ryan, R. M. y Deci, E. L. (2000). Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being. American Psychologist, 55(1), 68–78.

  • Deci, E. L., Olafsen, A. H. y Ryan, R. M. (2017). Self-determination theory in work organizations: The state of a science. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 4, 19–43.

 

Comments


bottom of page